Toa Payoh Vets Clinical
Research Making veterinary surgery alive
to a veterinary student studying in Australia
using real case studies and pictures
An Offer He
Should Not Refuse?
Dr Sing Kong Yuen,
BVMS (Glasgow), MRCVS
First written:
Oct 28, 2009
Edited: Nov 8, 2009
"It
costs S$400,000 (US$280,000) for a Singaporean
student to study veterinary
medicine in Australia," one young lady veterinarian
informed me. This is a large amount. Around 3-4
veterinary scholarships may be
awarded per year. Therefore the
majority of the new graduates in private practice is
privately funded, usually by parents.
In 2009, the Australian dollar once again shot up by
30% within a year. That greatly increases cost for
the parents. What happens if parents cannot support
a student halfway through the course? I often wonder whether
such a veterinary undergraduate in dire
financial straits would
succeed in the face of adversity?
Every year, he
would need $80,000 to pay the fees and the
accommodation as the course lasts 5 years prior to
2009 for most veterinary schools
in Australia. Murdoch now demands
6 years.
A car is needed to travel to farms and
university but I often wonder how poorer students
can afford a car. A 10-year-old old car costs around
S$3,000 in Perth, Australia unlike $30,000
- $40,000 in
Singapore. On my visit to the Willetton suburb of Perth
recently, I stayed in a house.
Each of the 5 undergraduate
students sharing a house possessed
a car. If you relate to the
Singapore situation, none of them
would possess one since an old
bomb would cost $30,000.
No matter how we view it, when you are
down and out,
$3,000 is a lot of money.
I
visited Murdoch University Veterinary School in
October 2009 to attend its continuing
education and was surprised to see a student
volunteer group providing free bread and butter for
students usually from overseas. I had presumed that there were no poor
overseas undergraduates in Murdoch University.
Just as Singaporeans presume that
all Indonesian Chinese in
Singapore are wealthy.
I doubt you will see such a group in Singapore's
University. There must be a need for free breakfast
by poorer students, presumably from Asia. These
volunteers are very kind to help out those in need.
What is the name of this social conscious volunteer group, I don't know.
There will always be disadvantaged
undergraduates who cannot afford
to eat breakfast as their parents
fall on hard times or lose their
income. Volunteers providing free
breakfast at Murdoch University,
during my visit in Oct 2009.
After seeing this admirable group
doing good social work, I had a question
in the back of my mind: "Are there any young
veterinarian who has had worked his way through college?"
Are all private students from well-to-do families
since
$400,000 is not a small sum to finance the study of veterinary medicine in Australia.
If you believe in divine powers,
my question was answered by my
meeting with one young vet one
month after I returned from
Murdoch University. He was personable and
chatty. I knew he loved
veterinary medicine from the way he talked about the
patients and exotic cases like a star tortoise in
his practice and how he prepared
for his video-examined
presentation during the 5th year.
The Murdoch Vet School has this
room where a video camera is
installed at the corner of a
ceiling in a room facing the door
entrance. In this room, the 5th year
student would act as a
"veterinarian"
interacting with selected real pet
owners. The student's actions would be
video-taped and the student
critiqued and evaluated.
"Did you see the video camera?"
the young vet asked me when I
brought up the subject of this
method of training students for
the real world.
"Yes," I said. "If one is not
observant, one will not see it. It
is rather substantial and obvious. A Heart Specialist and I were
shown the inner set up of the
Murdoch University Vet School
when I attended the Continuing
Education Course in Cardiology recently.
"The Cardiologist who is an
excellent lecturer mumbled to me
that he was glad that no such
video set up existed during his
student years.
I shared his sentiments.
Fortunately I did not have this
'Smile, You are on candid camera'
video evaluation
stress during my 5th year at
Glasgow University."
But times have changed since 1973
when I was in my 5th year. The young ones nowadays
are much more sophisticated and
showy. My female classmates in
Glasgow University 1969-1974 were
all dressed like hippies compared
to the present cohort. Some female
undergraduates have excellent
grooming and
make up. They wear branded dresses and
shoes and carry LV handbags. If
you don't know what "LV" is, it is
Louis Vutton. Notebooks (or
laptops for young readers who may
take the meaning of notebook
literally) in 1969-1974 were made of
paper and not electronics. Telephone calls home to
Singapore were too expensive and
seldom made by either parent or
child.
"So, how did you do the
video-show? Is there a
script? Did you rehearse before
action begins?"
"Well," the young graduate said,
"Professional actors will give a
demonstration and act according to
some situations in a scripted
card."
He continued: "The dog owner must be informed
as consent is needed. One must
select a good owner, somebody who
has a helpful and kind
personality. Then I whispered to
the owner coming into the video
room with the dog:
'I am being
'graded'."
I was impressed with his
reinforcement of grading thus
starting a
pre-emptive strike at the heart of
the video examination system.
He was no dumb blonde, another
stereotypical thinking. Many
Australian undergraduates at
Murdoch University have blonde
hairs during my October visit and
I am sure they are not dumb, being
cream of the young crop to attend
university.
The young man continued: "You also
have to choose a small dog as it
is easier to examine it. Otherwise
you have to bend down and struggle
with a big breed and the camera
can't film what you are doing."
I had not thought that the choice
of dog is so crucial to the
success. This young man had
analysed the situation and know
what factors contributed to
success.
I would probably have had chosen
an unco-operative owner and a
ferocious Rottweiler. I would have
got bitten, the owner would have
shown great displeasure and I
would have failed the video
performance.
"So, how did you do it? Did you ace this grading?" I
asked this young vet whom I
deem to be a heart-breaker. He was
single and eligible and together
with a Porsche sports car,
most feminine hearts of his
generation will suffer from
ventricular arrhythmia.
"I will introduce myself as a
student and explain to the dog
owner that I am preparing the dog
for the vet after doing the
initial check up. The owner smiled
and at the end of my check-up, she
said 'Very good work! Well done.'"
That meant an extra point to this
young man, I am sure.
All this action would then be
shown to all students and
criticised. A good actor will be
necessary in real veterinary
setting and so this training is
necessary. Who would want to
consult a vet who acts wooden? So
this training is a good thing.
"Do you kiss the dog in practice?"
I asked him. "Did Murdoch Vet
School professors teach you that
kissing dogs will endear you to
dog owners?" One vet is
known to do this in Singapore and
the owners will send their dog to
the groomer before seeing this
vet. This was what the groomer
told me. This vet has a
flourishing practice.
"No," the young man said. "Many
dogs have bad breath."
Back to my quest as to whether
there is any vet working his way
through vet school, like some
successful Hollywood actors
working as waitress in acting
schools, this young vet was one
such person.
During his 4th year at Murdoch University, the
Australian Dollar shot up by at least 20%. His
savings ran out. He found difficulty in paying the
room rental.
"Didn't your
parents support you?" I asked him when I meet him at
a networking session. From the way he nodded
his head and gave no comments, I don't think that
support was sufficient. $80,000/year is a killer
amount for the majority of Singapore's middle-class
parents as that meant one parent had to earn at
least $7,000 per month before taxes to support a
child. Money meant for retirement. The median income
in Singapore, I believe, is $3,000
for a family of four.
"What did you do to support yourself through
school?" I was curious.
"I played the baroque,." he said or some words
sounding like "baroque". I did not ask him so as not
to show my ignorance of music or musical
instruments.
"One evening, on the eve of examinations, I was
performing. I saw my two lecturers in the audience.
Immediately my mind went blank - I forgot my song!"
He was asked whether he could play the organ at the
Church. He had not much time as 4th year was a high
pressure-cooker year. So, music gave him some money to fund his
education. He was in the 4th year
and that was the most demanding year of lectures.
The 5th year was relatively relaxed as the student
does more clinical
cases. The Veterinary Hospital
accepts 82 undergraduates and a small number will be
rejected. He needed to spend the time to study. If he
failed the 4th year, he would have to repeat another
year.
"Would revenue generated from music be sufficient to
put you through college since I
presumed you had minimal, parental support ?" I
asked. "How much do you pay for
room accommodation?" I asked.
Rentals can be as much as $300 per
week in some universities like
Sydney.
"I met an old classmate from Singapore. Her family
had a house near where I rented a room. She had a spare bedroom
and offered to let me have this
room to make ends meet."
A guardian angel sometimes appear if one believes in
the divine phenomenon.
"Do you have to marry the daughter?" I presumed the
old classmate was single. Their paths had crossed in
Perth.
The girl's parents were very wealthy. He got along well
with the visiting parents and sang with them after
dinner.
The girl's mum liked him very much. All mums
would want a good spouse for their child and being a
parent myself, I would say, he was good husband
material - a boy-next-door veterinarian if he
graduates.
Well brought up to respect
elders and hard working despite financial setbacks.
Not a rich man's son zooming
around in a Lotus sports car and
partying.
The girl's parents offered him a
share to establish and operate a big piggery
operation in Xiamen after graduation. His
veterinary training and hard working characteristics would
add immense value to this new business venture. Pork
is in great in prospering China.
So this was a great business opportunity to be
richer.
He was not into pigs.
"How about setting up your own veterinary hospital in Singapore
since Singapore has only one veterinary hospital?"
the girl's father proposed this
venture.
This young man had an offer he
should not refuse. In this veterinary hospital, he
would have all the modern equipment that a clinic
with its small space could not accommodate. His
prospective in-laws has the necessary money to buy
the best and latest equipment, making this the
Veterinary Hospital all Singaporeans will flock to.
The girl's father said, "You just be the
Chairman. There
will be a Chief Executive. It will have veterinary
specialists from overseas. Pretty nubile young nurses and
receptionists to attract clients and to provide the best services.
Most clients prefer sweet young
things rather than matronly
frontline staff.
"This hospital will
also have A CT-MRI scanner. It will be the referral
center for all the cases from the feeder veterinary
clinics," the girl's father knew what to
do.
So, this was an offer he should not refuse as he
would just be an ordinary veterinary employee after
graduation.
In addition, he had an opportunity to move up the
social ladder. A well respected owner-vet of a most
modern veterinary hospital in Singapore, hob-nobbing
with the higher strata of
Singapore's society. He would elevate the
standard of veterinary care in Singapore. His
financial backing was solid. Such opportunities
don't come to anyone in a life-time. What would you do if you were
in his shoes? Say yes, yes, yes?
"Didn't the girl object to mum's proposal of an
arranged marriage?" I asked. Well, he knew the girl
first in Singapore and this was not really an
arranged marriage. A marriage of convenience? Not
exactly as he was getting to know her.
"No," he said.
"So, what's the problem? Don't you love her?"
The young man quoted me two Chinese idioms in the
course of our conversation regarding good heroes and
sourness in fruits. I don't know how to
translate as my grasp of Chinese language is no
good. I knew what he meant. In essence, one cannot
be man enough to rely on a woman's
financial support to succeed in
life or marry a girl of a different
behaviour.
This is the second time I hear of a similar
occurrence where the stars bring together a daughter
from a very rich family with a young male
undergraduate from a poor family. The daughters in
both cases had no objections to the marriage and
had offered to help the poor man financially.
The upbringing of a daughter in a very rich family
is so much different from that of a girl from a poor
family. She has everything and gets pampered to her
every wish and fancy. Shopping for branded goods and
clothes most of the time. Salvatore Ferragamo shoes
at $1,000 a pair and several pairs
worn once kept in the cupboard.
Handbags costing $5,000 each.
What do you expect her to
do since she has the money? She has no respect for
the elders usually as they cater to her every whim
and fancy from childhood. But this may be stereotypical thing as
there are rich girls who are frugal and make good
wives.
But
can the poor man give her the high standard of
living she is accustomed to? Will she really respect him for being an
opportunist enough to marry her?
Love had
not blossomed yet in this case. The room was the
bait. The young man was hooked.
And the girl's mum could see that
this was a good man. He offered to wash the dishes when the mum
cooked. Many young men would not even offer to wash
the dishes as they don't do it in
Singapore. The daughter, I presumed, would just let the
mum do all the washing and cooking.
The mum was from the baby-boomer generation that
knew hardship. She cooked and her maid washed dishes.
She wanted what all mums want. A good husband for
her daughter. But when the daughter has all the
monies of a wealthy family to indulge in, her
character changes. Her mindset and personality
change. She becomes high-maintenance, in my
stereotypical thinking of the average rich young
woman.
It was probably premature for the
parents to make a
proposal to finance the setting up of a veterinary hospital for him in
Singapore.
This proposal is one that can sabotage
any budding young adult relationship as any
responsible,
independent and intelligent man will be scared off.
If he succeeds, his wife will say, "If not for my
parents' money, you are nobody." If he fails, people
will say, "This opportunistic good-for-nothing is a
gold digger and useless." So, what should this young
man in such a situation do?
Did the poor young undergraduate men in both cases I
encounter marry the girl for her money? No. In this
second case, I felt that the mum had sabotaged
whatever relationship this daughter could have
developed if she had the time.
It would be better for parents to be
hands-off in matters of the heart.
So, there was no living together happily ever after
in these two cases. Some young men studying overseas
will meet and befriend girls from
extremely wealthy families - a
situation they may not encounter
while studying in Singapore as the
rich girls are usually from
foreign countries studying in the
U.K, Australia and USA. Their
wealth can last 3 generations at
least and herein lies an
opportunity to move up the social
ladder. Offers to succeed in life
may be proposed. Should such young
men accept offers he should not
refuse? I have no answer.